With so many Christian messages circulating through sermons, social media, and worship lyrics, it can be hard to tell what’s truly biblical and what’s just cleverly packaged. Not everything that sounds spiritual or mentions Jesus is grounded in God’s Word.

If you’ve ever listened to a sermon or worship song and felt that something was off, but couldn’t explain why, this is for you. Scripture doesn’t just allow us to test teaching; it commands it. The goal isn’t to tear down but to stay anchored in truth.

That’s why I’ve put together a biblical framework you can use to test what you’re hearing, not to be critical of every sermon, but to stay grounded in truth. This isn’t about judging people, but about learning to recognize healthy teaching from harmful distortion. And because pulling verses out of context is part of the problem, we’ll walk through the historical and theological background of each one.


1. What Gospel Is Being Preached?

Question to ask: Does this message point me to Jesus’ finished work or to my own effort, emotions, or potential?

Watch out for:

  • Messages that focus on your destiny more than Jesus’ death and resurrection.
  • Sermons that use Jesus’ name but center on self-help, motivation, or success.

Galatians 1:6–9

“I am astonished that you are so quickly deserting the one who called you to live in the grace of Christ and are turning to a different gospel… If anybody is preaching to you a gospel other than what you accepted, let them be under God’s curse!”

Galatians is one of Paul’s most urgent letters, written to believers who were abandoning salvation by grace and turning to legalism. Judaizers were teaching that Gentile converts had to adopt Jewish laws, especially circumcision, to be saved. Paul fiercely defends the sufficiency of Christ’s work on the cross. His point? Adding anything to the gospel makes it no gospel at all. If a teacher puts the spotlight on your ability rather than Christ’s, that’s a distortion.

Dive into this post to learn more.


2. Is Scripture Central Or Just Sprinkled In?

Question to ask: Is the Bible being explained in context, or are verses used as decoration?

Watch out for:

  • Verses that seem to appear out of nowhere, without understanding the surrounding passage.
  • Scripture that’s used to back up a point, rather than shape the point.

2 Timothy 2:15

“Do your best to present yourself to God as one approved, a worker who does not need to be ashamed and who correctly handles the word of truth.”

Paul is guiding Timothy as he leads the church in Ephesus, where false teachings and arguments were threatening to divide the congregation. Paul urges Timothy to cut straight, to “rightly divide” the Word. In Greek, the phrase implies a careful, precise handling of Scripture. This reminds us that biblical teaching isn’t about pulling verses to fit a message, but letting the message be shaped by the Word.

The context of Scripture truly matters. This is why.


3. Is God Glorified Or Is the Stage the Star?

Question to ask: Does this message lead me to worship God or to admire a personality or platform?

Watch out for:

  • Teachers who reference themselves more than Christ.
  • Environments that feel like entertainment but lack reverence.

1 Corinthians 2:1–5

“When I came to you, I did not come with eloquence or human wisdom… I resolved to know nothing while I was with you except Jesus Christ and him crucified… so that your faith might not rest on human wisdom, but on God’s power.”

Corinth was a city that prized showmanship and rhetorical skill. Paul deliberately rejected that cultural pressure by preaching plainly and humbly. He refused to build faith based on persuasion or performance. His goal was to anchor the church in Christ’s power, not his own eloquence. That’s the test: Does the ministry impress you or transform you?

The ESV Study Bible is hands down my favorite. It’s packed with context, maps, commentary, and notes that help make Scripture clearer without watering it down.

This is the exact one I use!
It’s deep, solid, and totally worth it.


4. What Foundation Is Being Built?

Question to ask: Is this helping me follow Jesus in hardship, or just promising me favor and ease?

Watch out for:

  • A constant emphasis on breakthrough, promotion, and blessings.
  • Lack of teaching on suffering, perseverance, or the cost of discipleship.

Luke 9:23

“Whoever wants to be my disciple must deny themselves and take up their cross daily and follow me.”

Jesus had just revealed to His disciples that He would suffer and die. He follows that shocking statement by telling the crowd what it truly means to follow Him: daily self-denial, surrender, and sacrifice. In the first century, carrying a cross wasn’t a metaphor, it was a death sentence. Jesus wasn’t promising comfort; He was inviting them into costly, obedient love. Real teaching should prepare us for that road.

Ever wondered what it means to actually pick up your cross? Read this.


5. Are Hard Truths Being Softened?

Question to ask: Does this teaching include the full counsel of God or just the comforting parts?

Watch out for:

  • Avoiding sin, judgment, repentance, or holiness.
  • Teaching that only ever affirms but never convicts.

Acts 20:27

“For I have not hesitated to proclaim to you the whole will of God.”

Paul is speaking to the elders of the Ephesian church in what he knows will be a final farewell. He warns them that false teachers will come, even from among their own ranks. But Paul finds peace knowing he didn’t hold back, he gave them everything God said, not just the encouraging bits. Biblical teaching doesn’t avoid conviction; it calls us into repentance and truth.


6. Does It Produce Fruit or Just Feelings?

Question to ask: Am I being transformed or just temporarily inspired?

Watch out for:

  • Constant emotional highs without lasting spiritual depth.
  • Messages that feel good but don’t lead to obedience or Christlikeness.

Matthew 7:16–20

“By their fruit you will recognize them… A good tree cannot bear bad fruit, and a bad tree cannot bear good fruit.”

Jesus is wrapping up His Sermon on the Mount, warning against false prophets who look the part but lead people astray. He uses a farming metaphor: you don’t judge a tree by its bark, but by its fruit. It’s the long-term evidence, changed hearts, repentance, spiritual growth, that proves the source is godly. Hype fades. Fruit lasts.

I did a whole podcast on the fact that faith is NOT simply a vibe. Check it out here!


Staying Grounded in Truth

If you’re navigating online sermons, devotionals, worship playlists, or Christian influencers and wondering, “Is this really biblical?” this post is your anchor. It’s designed to give you a reliable framework for biblical discernment that you can return to over and over again.

Want to go deeper in practicing discernment? Start by reading this post: Jesus Is the Light That Darkness Cannot Touch , it walks through how to study Scripture using observation, interpretation, and reflection, which pairs perfectly with this framework.

More posts are coming soon on how to recognize false gospels, study context well, and navigate tough topics like judgment and spiritual hype. And if you want a simple, printable reference to keep with your Bible, grab the free guide: 5 Questions to Help You Spot Biblical Truth in Any Teaching.

Testing what you hear isn’t being judgmental, it’s being faithful.

Discernment isn’t about tearing others down; it’s about building your foundation on truth. You don’t need to be a scholar or a critic to ask, Does this align with the gospel? Does this glorify Jesus? Does this help me grow in obedience and holiness?

If you’ve walked through all six questions above and something still feels off, trust that prompting. God gives us His Word and His Spirit so we can know Him rightly, not just emotionally, but truthfully.

You don’t have to name names. You don’t have to pick fights. But you do have to stay grounded. Stay rooted in the Word. Stay teachable and alert. And keep asking: Is this bearing fruit that lasts?

Because if it’s not leading you to love Jesus more and live more like Him, it’s not worth building your faith on.

Some of the links in this post are affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you choose to make a purchase at no extra cost to you. I only share resources I genuinely love and believe will serve you well. Thanks for supporting the work I do through Me and Jesus.

18 responses to “How to Biblically Test Teaching: 6 Questions for Discernment”

  1. […] You can’t preach the gospel and avoid Scripture. And you can’t rightly handle Scripture if you’re only using the parts that support your opinions or brand. A gospel that never mentions sin, judgment, repentance, or obedience is a half-truth—and a half-truth is still a lie. If the message doesn’t line up with the whole Word of God, it’s not the gospel. If you need help discerning biblical truth from opinion, this post will walk you through it. […]

  2. […] if you want help digging deeper, this post will help you recognize sound doctrine, and this one unpacks how to handle spiritual doubt without twisting the […]

  3. […] If you need help learning how to do that, I created a discernment guide you can check out here. […]

  4. […] We don’t get to follow Jesus and stay exactly the same. The call to take up your cross is a call to let go of self-rule. It’s the death of the idea that life is about you. The cross exposes the lie that you can serve God and still live for your own glory.→ If you’re unsure what’s actually biblical and what just sounds spiritual, this post will help you test it. […]

  5. […] Read more about how to test what you’re being taught […]

  6. […] → This post breaks down how to recognize real doctrine and test everything you hear. […]

  7. […] Related: How to Test What You’re Being Taught […]

  8. […] The same tactic still works today. This is why we need to know how to cut through the noise, test what we hear, and build confidence in discerning truth from error. […]

  9. […] → This post breaks down how to recognize real doctrine and test everything you hear. […]

  10. […] We don’t get to follow Jesus and stay exactly the same. The call to take up your cross is a call to let go of self-rule. It’s the death of the idea that life is about you. The cross exposes the lie that you can serve God and still live for your own glory.→ If you’re unsure what’s actually biblical and what just sounds spiritual, this post will help you test it. […]

  11. […] something painfully familiar about the Corinthian church.They were bold, gifted, charismatic, and totally […]

  12. […] want you to believe anything I say just because I sound confident or passionate. Be skeptical. Test everything you hear, including from me, against the Word of […]

  13. […] and Jesus blog, YouTube, or podcast.➡️ Don’t just take my word for it. Go read the Word and test everything against […]

  14. […] might be a youth leader, small group mentor, pastor, or even a close friend. Don’t rush. Pray for discernment and trust that the Holy Spirit will lead you to the right […]

  15. […] 6, Paul outlines the Armor of God, describing each piece believers must “put on” to stand firm against the schemes of the enemy. Yet many teachings stop short, ignoring the critical instruction that immediately follows the list […]

  16. […] The Day of the Lord is not just about judgment for them, it’s a call to readiness for us. […]

  17. […] Test the message against Scripture.No YouTube sermon, podcast (even this one!), or social post replaces your time in the Word. Test […]

  18. […] The tension isn’t new, though. Followers of Christ have always wrestled with the pull between faithfulness and fame, truth and attention. […]

Leave a Reply

I’m Karleigh

Welcome to Me & Jesus, a blog and podcast dedicated to biblical literacy and being on fire for the Lord. My goal is to get you into your Bible to grow our relationship with God. Nothing is off limits here – from learning the basics of salvation to overcoming lust addiction, I talk about it all. I’m so glad you’re here!

Let’s connect

Deepen your prayer-life with this free 10-day prayer journal! Click here to grab it.

Discover more from The Me and Jesus Podcast

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading