Daniel 12:2-3 speaks of people waking from death, and it did not come out of nowhere. The wording echoes Isaiah, which in turn echoes Genesis. Seeing that chain changes how we read all three.

I have been working through Gary Schnittjer’s Old Testament Use of Old Testament, which traces how Scripture interprets earlier Scripture. Before we look at Daniel, it helps to understand three tools from his chapter “Toward the New Testament.”

Three tools for reading Scripture with Scripture

The first tool is progressive revelation. Schnittjer writes that “the comprehensive scope of revelation in Israel’s Scriptures bearing witness to the gospel appears in many places.”¹ He notes that Jesus told His opponents that Moses “wrote about me.” Schnittjer adds that “the new revelation connects with revelation in Israel’s Scriptures.” In other words, dismissing the Old Testament cuts the New Testament off from its roots.

The second tool is vertical context, which Schnittjer defines as “cited scriptural texts that themselves feature exegesis of other Scriptures.”² So a passage can draw on an older passage, and we need to ask what older Scripture it pulls from.

The third tool is paradigmatic shaping, which Schnittjer explains with Jesus’ good Samaritan story. He suggests that Jesus reuses details from 2 Chronicles 28:12-15, but that reuse “is not of itself exegetical.” The exegetical part is how Jesus “leverages the riddle to interpret Lev 19:18, 34.”³ That is a helpful reminder that not every echo is a commentary. In Schnittjer’s words, “exegetical relationship requires a donor text and exegetical outcomes in the receptor text.”⁴

Daniel 12:2-3 as a test case

Here is Daniel 12:2 in the ESV: “And many of those who sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake, some to everlasting life, and some to shame and everlasting contempt.” Verse 3 adds that “those who are wise shall shine like the brightness of the sky above.” Schnittjer argues that Daniel is building on Isaiah.

The evidence starts with shared words. The word “contempt(ible)” appears only in Isaiah 66:24 and Daniel 12:2, “making a relationship likely.”⁵ He is careful about it, though. Bringing together such widely separate passages only “somewhat favors” Isaiah as the source. He follows that direction of dependence in his study.

Isaiah, in turn, draws on Genesis. Schnittjer points to the use of “dust” for death and the banishment from the “tree of life” in Genesis 3:19, 22. He says these details “demonstrate the broader context of Isaiah’s oracles and Daniel’s vision.”⁶

What Daniel adds to Isaiah

Isaiah 26:19 “uses the term ‘awake’ metaphorically to speak of rising from ‘the dead.’” Daniel extends the imagery by speaking of death as “sleep.” Schnittjer concludes that “the vision of Daniel looks ahead to physical resurrection.”⁷

Daniel also adds something new. Isaiah 26:19 “refers only positively to arising to rejoice.” Daniel goes further and supplies “a duality of those arising to judgment” by using the contempt language of Isaiah 66:24. In Schnittjer’s words, “Daniel’s vision interprets the prophecies of Isaiah by other prophecies of Isaiah.”⁸

This also prepares the way for the New Testament. Schnittjer says Daniel’s twofold resurrection “lends itself naturally to further advancement” in the New Testament. He points to John 5:29, Acts 24:15, and Revelation 20:4-5.⁹

How this helps us as readers

Seeing these connections helps us in at least two ways. First, one pass over a verse is not enough, since Daniel 12:2 opens up when we ask what older Scripture it draws on. Second, it brings the promise of resurrection to life, because Daniel’s vision speaks in the language of earlier Scripture.

I looked at another example of Scripture building on earlier Scripture in my post on Psalm 8 and Genesis 1. That is one more reason why Old Testament context matters, and the Old Testament is hard to understand without some help.

If you want a visual reminder to suit up in the Armor of God every day, grab the Prepare for Battle sticker! This handmade die-cut sticker is laminated and waterproof, designed to withstand whatever battle you’re fighting today. Head over to the sticker shop to check it out!

Questions to think through

Daniel 12:2-3 shows that Scripture explains itself. Daniel’s vision carries Isaiah’s promises forward, and the New Testament carries them further.

If you want to keep going deeper in Scripture, you can check out the Bible study here.

Notes

  1. Gary Edward Schnittjer, Old Testament Use of Old Testament: A Book-by-Book Guide (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan Academic, 2021), 848–849.
  2. Ibid., 850.
  3. Ibid., 854.
  4. Ibid.
  5. Ibid., 625.
  6. Ibid.
  7. Ibid., 626.
  8. Ibid.
  9. Ibid.

Bibliography

Schnittjer, Gary Edward. Old Testament Use of Old Testament: A Book-by-Book Guide. Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan Academic, 2021.

Leave a Reply